Jakob Weinrich, M.A., LL.M.

Gifting an Apartment Building to Minors: When the Court Says No

A rental property in a prime Viennese location given as a gift to one’s own children—it sounds like a generous way to set the stage for the future. A recent decision by the Supreme Court (OGH 4 Ob 5/25a dated February 25, 2025) shows that such a transfer can fail: The guardianship court refused to grant approval, and the Supreme Court upheld this decision across the board.

What had happened?

An aunt wanted to gift an apartment building in Vienna’s First District to her two minor nieces and nephews—aged twelve and ten. The children were to hold title to the property; however, the aunt reserved the right of usufruct and was also granted a prohibition on encumbering or selling the property. The aunt, in her capacity as the usufructuary, was to bear the costs and expenses associated with the house. The father was liable for all of the children’s expenses until they reached the age of majority.

The guardianship court refused to approve the gift agreement because it did not serve exclusively the best interests of the children. The appeal and the appeal for review were unsuccessful.

The Key Point of the Supreme Court's Ruling

The guardianship court may approve a legal transaction only if it is in the best interests of the ward. At first glance, this may seem self-evident—but what matters is how the Supreme Court interprets this: The decisive factor is not only the situation during the ward’s minority, but also the period thereafter.

That was precisely the problem. The aunt had obtained a registration prohibiting encumbrance and sale in her favor. This means that as soon as the children reach the age of majority and the father is no longer liable, they cannot freely dispose of the property—neither sell it nor encumber it. At the same time, costs may arise that go beyond the legal framework applicable to usufructuaries: For example, the law provides for exceptions to the usufructuary’s obligation to bear costs in cases such as construction supervision, the owner’s obligations under public law, or extraordinary repairs. A reduction in the children’s assets could not be ruled out—and that was sufficient for the Supreme Court to deny approval.

What does that mean in practice?

This decision is not an isolated case, but rather reflects the strict standard of review that guardianship courts apply to real estate transfers to minors. Gifts that appear advantageous at first glance become problematic if they are linked to consideration, encumbrances, or third-party rights of use that restrict the children’s future capacity to act.

Anyone wishing to transfer real property to a minor must draft the contract in such a way that it will withstand judicial review. Specifically, this means: The allocation of costs must be clearly and fully defined; restrictions on the child’s right to dispose of the property are problematic; and the child’s financial situation upon reaching the age of majority must be taken into account. A right of usufruct for the donor is not per se impermissible—but the overall structure of the contract must be reasonable at every stage of the child’s life.

Conclusion

The Supreme Court makes it clear: guardianship courts look beyond the age of majority. A real estate transfer to a minor is not merely a matter of tax or estate planning, but a transaction that must serve exclusively the best interests of the child—and this must be verifiable. Anyone who wants to play it safe should have the contract structure reviewed by a lawyer at an early stage.

As a law firm specializing in real estate and family law, we advise you on how to structure property transfers to minors in a legally sound manner—from the initial assessment through to approval by the guardianship court.

Let's talk about it

Is your situation different from the one described in the article? During our initial consultation, we'll determine what applies to your specific situation.

Schedule an appointment or call: +43 1 997 41 21